Irish parents divided over teacher's 'ruling' on answer to this kid's maths question

Irish parents divided over teacher's 'ruling' on answer to this kid's maths questionplaceholder image
Irish parents divided over teacher's 'ruling' on answer to this kid's maths question

Irish parents have been clashing on Twitter over a teacher's 'ruling' on the correct answer to a maths question in a child's school book. 

Sunday Independent journalist Mark Tighe shared a photograph of a child's work book with a number of maths problems.

He claimed there was a "controversial ruling" from the teacher to a questions about the number of corners in a semi-circle.placeholder image
He claimed there was a "controversial ruling" from the teacher to a questions about the number of corners in a semi-circle.

The child answered '2' but was deemed incorrect by the teacher with the correct answer being marked as '0'.

Tighe captioned his post: "Hmm. Controversial ruling from the múinteoir here on "how many corners does a semi-circle have."

A number of other people reacted with the question very much dividing opinion.

One said "lodge an appeal" while another suggested a "VAR" check.

Someone else said: "If you define corner as a 90-degree angle between two lines, then yeah none."

Another primary school teacher even chimed in to suggest the child was right with their answer. 

He posted: "I reckon there’ll be some argue this, but your child seems to be right. If the definition of a corner is where two lines meets, but doesn’t specifically state it has to be straight lines, then a semi-circle has 2 corners. But, if the definition being used is two straight lines, then it’s 0. "

Another woman added: "It should be vertices, not corners. Just saying."

We are still divided on this one. Tell us what you think in the comments. 

Related topics:
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice